This October, PenMet Parks board president Billy Sehmel walked the newest piece of the park district with Larry and Judy, the couple PenMet credits with the "stewardship and conservation" of nearly 21 acres next to Sehmel Homestead Park. By the time that walk came up in his October 20 board report, the land already had a name and a trailhead, and it was open to the public.
The forest is called Butterfield Forrest. PenMet opened it the week of October 21 with a short announcement. The ribbon-cutting comes later, with a community celebration planned for spring 2027. For anyone on the Artondale and Rosedale side of the peninsula who already walks Sehmel, the closest new trail in years has been sitting at the edge of the Meadow for about three weeks.
The trails were already there
Most new parks open after years of design and construction. This one opened with almost none, because the work had been done before the public arrived.
Larry Butterfield bought the land in the 1990s and spent nearly three decades turning former timberland into a diverse forest. When the park district reviewed the property in 2025, its board memo listed two bridges and soft-surface footpaths already on site. PenMet spokesperson Brynn Grimley explained the plan to The News Tribune in November 2025:
"... the really amazing thing about this property is the property owner actually had really taken great care of this land and created walking trails already on site, so our plan is to just continue that use of the property."
That explains the name. Butterfield asked the district to care for the forest and open it as a park, and PenMet named it after his father, Forrest, a logger who taught his son to conserve land from a young age. The double "r" in the name is intentional. His Puget Sound logging friends called him "Forrest."
A purchase built so nothing would change
The ownership chain also explains why the forest will stay much as Butterfield left it. Great Peninsula Conservancy, a regional land trust, bought the three parcels and closed the deal on Friday, November 21, 2025. The reported price was $1,245,000, and the money came from three places:
- $1,089,000 from Pierce County Conservation Futures
- $92,623 from the state's Salmon State Riparian program
- $63,377 in private donations, which PenMet's board memo traces to the Gig Harbor/Key Peninsula Land Fund and the Morris Family Foundation through the Rotary Club of Gig Harbor
That puts roughly 87 cents of every purchase dollar in the county's Conservation Futures column, money set aside for protecting land rather than building on it. The grants came with conditions to match. Great Peninsula Conservancy says the covenants limit the property to passive recreation and prohibit development. After the purchase, the land was given to PenMet, which has pledged to manage it for conservation and passive recreation.
The district's own case for buying the forest centered on its location. The board memo cited protecting streamside habitat and joining the land to Sehmel Homestead Park's protected open space. In Great Peninsula Conservancy's announcement, Billy Sehmel called the property "a rare remaining opportunity to extend an existing wildlife corridor and add to a beloved community space." Sehmel is a 98-acre site, and 76 of those acres are meadow, a pond, wetlands and a forest conservancy area. With Butterfield added, The News Tribune reported that the combined protected land tops 100 acres.
Nelyaly Creek runs through it
The stream is what made this land worth a riparian grant. More than half a mile of freshwater stream runs through the property, including over 1,000 feet of Nelyaly Creek.
Nelyaly Creek is small. The Wild Fish Conservancy describes it draining about 786 acres of homes and city parkland into Lay Inlet, where it widens into a long, narrow tidal estuary. Great Peninsula Conservancy's Ali Querin told The News Tribune that the creek "has documented use by coastal trout, coho, and chum salmon." She added that the estuary at the creek's mouth, about 1,000 feet from Butterfield Forrest, includes habitat used by Puget Sound Chinook salmon, which are listed as threatened.
In practice, a walk in Butterfield Forrest follows water that reaches salt water within about a fifth of a mile of the property line. That short distance is a big part of why conservation money funded the purchase. It also explains why PenMet's rules focus on what visitors leave alone.
Getting in from the Meadow
There is one way in. PenMet asks visitors to start at Sehmel Homestead Park, 10123 78th Ave NW, and use the parking lot closest to the Meadow. From there, a trail off the Meadow leads into the forest. Gig Harbor Now places the property south of Sehmel. PenMet specifically asks people not to enter from private access roads or from anywhere outside the Meadow trail.
| Before you go | What PenMet says |
|---|---|
| Entry | Trail off the Meadow at Sehmel Homestead Park |
| Parking | Lot closest to the Meadow |
| Hours | 7 a.m. to dusk, like all PenMet parks |
| Dogs | Leashed, outside designated off-leash areas |
| Closed areas | Some sections are closed for safety, and signs mark where to stay on the trail |
| Off-trail | No cutting new trails or building access |
| Reporting issues | 253-858-3400 during business hours, 253-255-0555 after hours, or [email protected] |
Dusk matters in mid-November, because the park closes in late afternoon. If you're going after work, plan on a short Sehmel loop with a stretch into the forest before dark, and save the longer walk for a weekend morning.
PenMet describes the forest as a sensitive ecosystem where unauthorized use could harm the environment. For regular Sehmel walkers, Butterfield adds new ground in one direction off the Meadow, not a way through to other roads. Sehmel's own network of about four miles of trails is on PenMet's Sehmel Park trails map.
Why the opening came late, and what's still coming
When Great Peninsula Conservancy announced the purchase in December 2025, it expected the forest to open in early 2026. At that point, Grimley told The News Tribune that safety assessments were still underway and that the district was still deciding how visitors would reach the forest, with the goal of starting them from Sehmel. The opening slipped to October, and the Meadow trail is the access route PenMet settled on. PenMet also says it spent that time learning the history of the land and the Butterfield family from Butterfield himself.
Two things are still ahead. Executive Director Ally Bujacich told the board that interpretive signs will tell the Butterfield story and explain the forest's ecosystem. The public is invited to the spring 2027 celebration, and PenMet says it will share details on the event and how to attend in 2027.
Until then, the forest is open on the terms Butterfield set when he asked PenMet to open it to the public, with the walking trails he created still in use.
A 21-acre forest added to a park you already walk is the kind of change that makes this side of the peninsula feel new again. If Sehmel is part of your week and you're thinking about what's next for your home, I'd love to hear what you find on the Meadow trail. Kate Diaz is always glad to talk about the places that make this side of the harbor home. Let's Connect.